To Everna and Beyond!

An exploration of Fantasy and Science Fiction Worlds in literature and multimedia entertainment
The official blog and novelblog for Evernade Saga and FireHeart Saga by Andry Chang

"Come forth, Paladins! Fulfill your destiny!"

Explore Worlds in Clicks

FireHeart Highlights!

Showing posts with label manga review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label manga review. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 04, 2011

Garudayana 3 - Comic Review by Peter Prabowo


Review and Commentary of Garudayana 3 by Is Yuniarto
by Peter Prabowo on Tuesday, May 3, 2011 at 9:06pm

Warning: In which the reviewer can relax

Author/Artist: Is Yuniarto

Title: Garudayana 3

Publisher: Koloni

Summary:

The fight between Gatotkaca and his brother, Antareja reached its climax. Gatotkaca was forced to use the Brajamusti (Thunder Fist) to deal with Antareja's Nagarupa (Dragon Form)...

I'm sure people who actually know about the legend can enjoy this book more than I do.

SPOILERS!!... KINDA

Review and Commentary

I was never interested in Shadow Puppet stories or Indonesian Legend in general. Maybe because I've read so many of it back in school days, in lesson textbook and library books, that I don't want to read them in fiction. Garudayana is an exception because it's not merely an adaptation of a legend, but a good story of it's own. The proof is how I can enjoy it without having prior knowledge of the story.

Is Yuniarto continue to provide us with high quality work. This book becomes the best one yet as new characters are introduced, back stories are told, and exciting actions explode from the pages. The plot and action is more balanced (though still lean more to the action) compared to volume 2, and humor take a back seat (but still very loud) compared to the first volume.

As I've said before Garudayana so far is the only series that doesn't make me facepalm or say flat what because of technical problems or unbelievable storytelling. So that means I can enjoy the story while giving my opinion like an ordinary reader, and if there's a protest, it will be out of taste.

In the first part, Arjuna fought with Antareja while comic relief Punakawan Trio cheering in the background, until Arjulas (coined by the author himself) was subdued and The Trio enter the battle. Needless to say they got pawned. Antareja fled when Arjuna threatened to use his strongest attack.

A fan letter mentioned that the battle scenes remind him of Naruto. Though I didn't realized this in volume 2, I can see why in this one. Giant Stoned Snake and Ice Jutsu Arrow for example. This is not a bad thing really. It's not like it was ripped off frame to frame. In fact, most anime battle I know is like this.

The next morning Kinara and Garudaboy (wink, wink ^^) reached a new village to find info on the artefact thy found back in volume 2. This lead to a partnership with a Mysterious Woman. Meanwhile Hakase Semar and his bodyguards reached Astina Camp, and we're told how they have to camp in the first place with a flashback.

Forgive me to say this your highness, but you're a bloody idiot.

Who gamble his kingdom and wife?

Against someone with THAT kind of face?

Yudhistira still feels guilty of what happened and Hakase Semar gives him a gentle pat

"KAKEK MENAMPAR RAJA!?" - "GRANDPA SLAPPED THE KING?!"

or that works too

"TAMPARAN KASIH!" - "THE SLAP OF LOVE!"

Oh shut up. You guys are getting annoying.

With past wrong forgiven, they discussed the mistery of Antareja

"KURAWA! PASTI KURAWA! YAKIN!!" - "THE KURAVA! MUST BE THE KURAVA! NO DOUBT!"

SHUT UP!!!

"KURAWA! JELAS KURAWA!" - "KURAVA! KURAVA FER SHURE!"

Pain.. strangling.. drowning.. whipping....

While Kirana's team reached Kalpataru forest. More actions happened (is that a Get Over Here! attack!?) where I have to ask are all monsters have that kind of jaw and expression? I call them the "Is's Trademark Monster Expression" or IT-ME, for short.

After some Stupid Summon advanced the plot, the reason for Antareja's behavior is revealed. Hilarious fighting ensues as Gatotkaca, Antareja and Kinara are reunited. The heroes are in critical condition after Garuda uses his Rashomon Gate to block the Mini Boss's attack and the Big Mini Boss gloat:

"Kau berani melawanku berarti kau melawan seratus Kurawa!" -
"Fight me, you fight 100 Kuravas too!"

Oh great, we still have 100 volumes ahead of us

"Jangankan seratus, seribu Kurawa pun aku tidak takut!"

"Let alone 100, 1000 Kuravas don't scare me!"

No, don't tempt the author. Seriously.

The story ends with my cringe as Kinara gets a Power Up.

No.

Just no.

Please tell me this is not permanent.

So I just have one question:

When are we going to see Nakula's equally cute Twin Brother?

Summary

Garudayana 3 continues to provide us with exciting action, humor, and enough mistery to keep us waiting for the next volume. I don't know if anyone who have read the original legend know what's coming, but I'm sure excited to read the next volume.

Final Verdict: 9 out of 10

Exciting from beginning to end


Retrieved from the article in this link.

Friday, April 01, 2011

Garudayana Vol 2 by Is Yuniarto - Peter's Review

Review and Commentary of Garudayana Vol 2 by Is Yuniarto

by Peter Prabowo on Saturday, March 26, 2011 at 7:24pm
Source: Link

Warning: This review is half spoiler, and half spoiler-free. Since I'm not sure which part is the spoiler for you and you're not sure which one I considered spoiler, even though that spoiler may not be spoiler at all, let's just play safe and say this review has spoilers.

Title: Garudayana 2

Author/Artist: Is Yuniarto

Editor: Gupta Mahendra S

Graphic Designer: Heru Lesmana

Publisher: Koloni

Summary:

From the creator of Wind Rider & Knights of Apocalypse Trilogy

Kirana the treasure hunter and the little Garuda departed to 'Sanda Nuai', the Cliff of Corpses to find a lead to the whereabouts of Kiskenda Cave. Meanwhile, in a fight with the Ashuras, Gatotkaca was shocked by the coming of a least expected foe...


I just have one question. Why does HE hog the whole cover?

Review

It's good. Carry on.

Final Verdict 8 out of 10

The only Indonesian comic book I enjoy more than Bleach or Naruto

Recommendation

Everyone

Okay ^^ I was just pulling your leg

but the rating stays.

Commentary

When I bought Garudayana 2, I was driving my mom to buy whatever it is she wanted to buy. I sat down, unwrap the book and read it the moment she said "wait here". I read, I laughed, I giggled, then she came back and we went home. I read it while having lunch, smiled again, and finished it before continuing work.

I did this whenever I bought a new Koloni (without the mum), but so far Garudayana 2 is the only Koloni book where I didn't have to raise eyebrow, say "what?", facepalm, or say a louder "WHAT!?". It is as enjoyable as a comic book can be, and although the art is not perfect (what does?) it doesn't stop me from enjoying the book. When I finished it, for the first time ever since reading Koloni books, I feel eager to read the next volume.

Kinara and Garuda continued their adventure to find the Elder Garudas. They took a side quest, Tomb Raiding to get the key to open a cave, which will give them clue to find the Elders. They brave the hilarious undead, while Legojuna escorted Hakase-Semar with the Trio. In a different place, Gatotkaca helps people while hunting other Ashuras (there isn't only one, apparently)

The battle between Gatotkaca and 3 Ashuras took the most part of the book, followed by the undead followed Kinara and Garuda to a World Map Random Village, while a mysterious character looked on. A new epic character is also introduced, someone well known by Gatotkaca and Legojuna, and attacked both of them.

If there's any weakness to this book, is that compared to the first, it doesn't have that much plot. It's basically a side quest plus mystery. A bridge to from the pilot to a series. Compared to the first action-packed, information-packed one, you may feel it a little empty, a little let down. Especially since you know you have to wait a year to get the next volume.

However as a bridge, the volume made to make us hyped up to the next, it's not bad. In fact, it's good. Since there's not much in it, we want to know more, and we want to wait for the next volume. So in that case it works. The time taken to produce the next volume kinda dampen it though.

But there's hope. The author has proven himself time and time again that he can produce wonderful works. A couple of assistants and the right sponsor, then maybe in a couple of years... no... let's be hopeful and say months... maybe we can get our first monthly (or bi-monthly) series.

So, anyone in Surabaya (nii-san, do you still live there?) go contact him.




Press X for grappling hook

Saturday, February 12, 2011

Hopper



A Re-Review by Peter Prabowo

source: http://www.facebook.com/notes/peter-prabowo/re-review-of-hopper-by-galang-tirtakusuma/303737444962

----------------------------

Title: Hopper

Author/Artist: Galang Tirtakusuma

Publisher: Koloni

Editor: Ardiatma Mardhika

Language: Indonesian Version

Graphic Designer: Heru Lesmana

Summary:

Hopper, a worker ant in Thundersmutz enrolled in the Dragon Team led by Lieutenant Comodo. His first mission was to investigate strange happenings in Sector 91. What considered as a simple, routine mission turned out to be a nightmare.

AHAHAHAHAHA!

Thundersmutz ^^

Okay look... don't combine English with Indonesian made up language.. particularly if that made up language sounds like English naught slang. Now the ants have a team that sounds like a porn movie.

Hopping Spoilers

In a land claimed to be Black Ants Country that looks more like Mushroom Kingdom, the working ants that... don't look like ants at all... more like miniaturized Konoha Ninja, work hard to be selected for Thundersmutz(lol), the kingdom's army.

There's Grass Hopper, the shonen hero not-ant, who wish to be SOLDIER instead of worker. Humboldt Pinguin (there's an ant parents named their son penguin.. I doubt they even seen any penguin) the smart not-ant. The Sakura not-ant and token childhood friend, Water Lily, a SOLDIER. All three of them formed Team 9.

They were attacked by Mech Bugs (just go with it. The not-ants ride bikes anyway) where Hopper proves himself more hardcore than any of the SOLDIER.

Mech Bugs came in the shapes of bigger insects like bees and tarantulas, but they're robots, not real bugs. Nobody know where they came from, some even think they're from outer space (I said just go with it) and the ants live with constant attack.

Team 9 was called and complimented by Lieutenant Komodo Dragon, who shrunk after failing to save Roxas I guess. He challenged Naruto to prove his worth by duelling him. Axel judged that Hopper's more suitable to become a WARRIOR than a SOLDIER because he dual wield. Axel asked his assistant, Jessica Alga (that's actually funny) to assign Team 9 to Sector 91.

They work together with Red Ants country army, Firesmutz(lol) riding on a Dragonflyer, red ants dragonfly helicopter. The only red ants introduced was Husky, who was apparently as loud as Hopper. They keep arguing until they're attacked by Sonic Scorpion in Sector 91.

They saved the village, and Hopper, who was prone to gazing to the distance while making heroic statement finally explain his motivation of becoming a SOLDIER. His father was one.

After that Lt. Axel Dragon brief them to rescue the villagers that were kidnapped in The Tunnel. The raid happened in an epic war where Axel was brainwashed by Brainx bugs. Confused won how they save their beloved leader, Hopper and Husky decided to.... bash him till he's unconscious. (facepalm)

In the end they bombed the tunnel, save the hostages, and defeated/saved Axel. Hopper considered to become a WARRIOR in the end.

Hopping Review

As opposed to what I said in my commentary, I really don't mind all the funny names, technology or ants that don't look like ants. Because whether or not they're ants or not isn't really important. Let's just say you don't call them Ant Colony but Mini People and it can still work. Mini People defend their villages from Mech Bugs. That's the story.

You may asked why I thought the story is "Mini People defending Village" instead of "Hopper becoming Warrior".

That's because Hopper as character is not interesting. At all. He's a typical shonen hero complete with Dead Awesome Dad and Hero Dream and Rush Without Thinking attitude. There is character growth, but very little. Though this little growth is realistic since the timeline is short, I wish he wasn't so two dimensional.

The world of Hopper is more interesting than Hopper itself.

Even though the concept and story is simple It doesn't look boring because of original visual design.

It take the concept of Ant Colony and created a whole new world that is unique and full of action.

I may complain that the ants don't look like ants, but since no one ever draw ants this way, it came out unique. So this is both the strength and weakness of the design. Other than that, the Mech Bugs are all exciting to look at. The enemies are vicious while the characters are cute and likeable.

I guess I was hoping for a more ant-like design but still unique. Hopper's design is too humanoid, even the antennae was replaced by hair-shaped antennae. A Bug's Life and Antz are more based on reality. I was looking for something in between. Something where you can tell that they're ants, but still wearing cool costumes.

In terms of art style... it's not my taste. I don't like that there's almost no tone because the art style is pretty flat and there's little difference in the thickness of the lines.Without tone I was faced with lots and lots of lines in front of white background and it makes my eyes tired. Especially during action shot. I have to struggle reading the book or making out what's happening. I can't enjoy seeing it.

Conclusion

With good design and concept, Hopper has a potential to be a series, if only the characters are more interesting than the currently shown. As of now, Hopper is a fun, loud, simple, light hearted adventure story. It didn't think too much, it didn't pretend to be smart or have a complex plot. It knows that it's a simple action with simple story, and that's what it is.

Final Verdict

7 out of 10

Simple and fun with unique design

Reccomended for

Light reading and happy time. All age.

BJ Vadis' comment: Ants and grasshoppers in nature, the visualization is just unique. Yet the story is simple and (hopefully) memorable. The characters are mostly typical, yet I documented Peter's review here with hope that someday someone might publish the English version of this "lightweight" manga. Another proof that Indonesian comic artists & authors are going global.

Friday, February 11, 2011

4Hero Manga by Mazjojo - A Re-review


Reviewed by: Peter Prabowo
Source: http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=303279839962

Publisher: Koloni

Title: 4Hero

Author/Artist: Mazjojo

Summary:

Unlike his schoolmates, Juno didn't like to play "Hero Line", the most popular online game in the world today. This highschool student in Surabaya prefers to be strong in the real world rather than in the virtual one. A good friend "half-forced" him to get along with this "digital lifestyle", so eventually Juno tried his hand on "Hero Line".

Strange, when he put on the virtual visor, Juno arrived in a mysterious place and met the "princess" who begged him to save her! After that a collision occured between the Hero Line gaming world and the real world in Surabaya!

The fate of the city Surabaya and the Hero Line world was in Juno's hands now.

-------------------

So... a jock become a gamer and all hell break loose? Sounds about right

BIRTH BY SPOILER

Okay before we begin, let's get the dirt out first.

The author is a Kingdom Hearts fan. Everybody who watch his DA knows that. I guess my main disappointment is how even though this book is 3 years in development, and during those time many people has pointed out that Juno's costume design is too much like Sora, and even though he did make an alternate design, that he obviously capable of creating unique character design, as proven by his other characters (Mazo Xelyzbulc curse my spelling), the author still keep the design that's too similar to Sora.

Though I understand that this is more a homage to his favorite game than a rip off, because Nomura's costume for Sora is so iconic, it WILL devalue the character/costume design, and should not be done for any new comic artist trying to stand on his own.

Another example: I also don't care if Laba-Laba Merah has different characterization, it's still Spider-man costume homage/rip off. End of story.

Kingdom 4Hero

The cover and the first 10 pages are awesome. I have never seen better artwork and it's the best looking, detailed, and crisp Koloni artwork to date. The line art isn't too thick or thin, great page composition and detailed background, great use of tone.

Unfortunately it all gone after that. Don't get me wrong, the artwork is still awesome, still the best out of all Koloni, but the quality has lessened somewhat. Obviously this is the case of deadline, and the intro are created when the author have the most time. Anyway, as I say, it's not bad. Let's say that if the intro is museum worthy artwork, the next chapters are regular comic artwork.

It's worth saying that the worst Mazjojo can offer you is still better than most Koloni artist out there.

Also, what I like about this book is how the sound effect is in Indonesian but it shaped like katakana. Not sure if this is good for purist, since it's not very Indonesian, but for those who like artistic manga sound effect, this is very good.

Character of Memories

The characters in 4Hero are, for a lack of better work, stock characters. We got:

- The Shonen Hero: Loud proud honorable pervert Juno

- The Childhood Love Interest: Dita

- The Butch Girl: Miirina

- Princess in Distress: The naked princess

- Geeky Best Friend: Ian

- Expendable Classmates Prone for Possession: All of them, but particularly Jack

The side characters I found more interesting, such as the wild warrior with stock footage of frustration, Arpharov and his bossy uke Lura (I think I'll just call him Laura)

However Royal Priest Cattelya looks too much like Beyond The Beyond flower and Royal Thief Kuranza remind me of someone too.. I just don't remember

and Carbuncle is the lovechild of Mokona and Pikachu, not helped that all Carbuncle supposed to look like that.

To be honest except Juno, Ian, Cattelya, and Carbuncle, other characters are well design. Miirina, especially. It's just their role in the story that's too cliche.

See how one derirative character design can mar judgement on others?

180/2 Nights

The monsters design are good. At first I thought they're just Heartless, but each of them has unique and cool design, actually look dangerous, but unfortunately they all black and attack in packs under the also black night and sound effects, so you have to squint to see the details. Pity.. if only they're more colorful, it can be great.

Kingdom 4Hero 2

Story... story is pretty simple, basically if you read the summary you already know the story. Jock learn about Kingdom Hearts Online, all hell breaks loose, and he must fight to save the world. Again there is nothing really new or unique in the story... except the online part. Online games are very popular in Surabaya. I live there at Ragnarok Online's hype years so I can attest to that. If done right this can be an interesting story.

Unfortunately we only see the stock characters do stuff all stock characters do. There's a feeling of "been there... done that" when you read it. The only unique and interesting part is the climax, when one friend get possessed and Arpharov and Lura show up to stir things up even more, but before that, it's a rather standard shonen adventure. There's almost no surprise.

Fortunately, even though the story is filled with cliche, it is helped by gorgeous artwork, exciting fight scenes, great humor, and plenty of fanservice, so it is still a very enjoyable read.

and no, I don't think that tentacle fanservice is too much. I actually forget it exist.

Coded

If you want to be cruel, you can call 4Hero style without substance.

If you want to be nice you can say that this book is one big homage to all anime cliche in existence.

I'll say it's a combination of the two. It is both a homage, and a newbie storyteller mistake. There's too much homage in the book that it took over the storyline. It is this that make the book seems shallow.

But what the heck.. you don't watch Avatar for the story right?

Dream Drop Distance

4Hero has a lot to live up to. Mazjojo is a great and popular artist and people will expect much of him, but.. I know it's still to early to say, but I have a feeling that unless 4Hero 2 prove otherwise, he is best to stay as an artist and let other people write the story. Combine the epic art of Mazjojo with a great writer, and you'll get a collectible worthy comic book. But as of now, it's still pretty standard.

4Hero 3

An enjoyable, mindless adventure with artwork that's second to none, but maybe a liiiitle too much homage. Followers of Mazjojo jump right in. People who want to read a meaningful story, however, exit stage left, or wait in line for the next volume and hope for the best.

8 out of 10

Saved from 7 because the art is just that good.

vadisworld - my way, my world

FireHeart Blog List

Vadis' Technorati Favourites

Pyr Publishing

Pat's Fantasy Hotlist

Sources and Studies Lookup

Online Reference
Dictionary, Encyclopedia & more
Word:
Look in: Dictionary & thesaurus
Computing Dictionary
Medical Dictionary
Legal Dictionary
Financial Dictionary
Acronyms
Idioms
Wikipedia Encyclopedia
Columbia Encyclopedia
by:

FireHeart Most Wanted!